Revert "certify_bootimg: support --extra_footer_args" am: dc7cea59b3

Original change: https://android-review.googlesource.com/c/platform/system/tools/mkbootimg/+/2113384

Change-Id: I428afe940d29d494242642f764f499ae4bca0f49
Signed-off-by: Automerger Merge Worker <android-build-automerger-merge-worker@system.gserviceaccount.com>
diff --git a/gki/certify_bootimg.py b/gki/certify_bootimg.py
index 68a042e..39dcaeb 100755
--- a/gki/certify_bootimg.py
+++ b/gki/certify_bootimg.py
@@ -132,7 +132,7 @@
     return 0
 
 
-def add_avb_footer(image, partition_size, extra_footer_args):
+def add_avb_footer(image, partition_size):
     """Appends a AVB hash footer to the image."""
 
     avbtool_cmd = ['avbtool', 'add_hash_footer', '--image', image,
@@ -143,7 +143,6 @@
     else:
         avbtool_cmd.extend(['--dynamic_partition_size'])
 
-    avbtool_cmd.extend(extra_footer_args)
     subprocess.check_call(avbtool_cmd)
 
 
@@ -161,24 +160,12 @@
     return d
 
 
-def load_gki_info_file(gki_info_file, extra_args, extra_footer_args):
-    """Loads extra arguments from the gki info file.
-
-    Args:
-        gki_info_file: path to a gki-info.txt.
-        extra_args: the extra arguments forwarded to avbtool when creating
-          the gki certificate.
-        extra_footer_args: the extra arguments forwarded to avbtool when
-          creating the avb footer.
-
-    """
+def load_gki_info_file(gki_info_file, extra_args):
+    """Loads extra args from |gki_info_file| into |extra_args|."""
     info_dict = load_dict_from_file(gki_info_file)
     if 'certify_bootimg_extra_args' in info_dict:
         extra_args.extend(
             shlex.split(info_dict['certify_bootimg_extra_args']))
-    if 'certify_bootimg_extra_footer_args' in info_dict:
-        extra_footer_args.extend(
-            shlex.split(info_dict['certify_bootimg_extra_footer_args']))
 
 
 def get_archive_name_and_format_for_shutil(path):
@@ -219,8 +206,6 @@
     # Optional args.
     parser.add_argument('--extra_args', default=[], action='append',
                         help='extra arguments to be forwarded to avbtool')
-    parser.add_argument('--extra_footer_args', default=[], action='append',
-                        help='extra arguments for adding the avb footer')
 
     args = parser.parse_args()
 
@@ -233,21 +218,13 @@
         extra_args.extend(shlex.split(a))
     args.extra_args = extra_args
 
-    extra_footer_args = []
-    for a in args.extra_footer_args:
-        extra_footer_args.extend(shlex.split(a))
-    args.extra_footer_args = extra_footer_args
-
     if args.gki_info:
-        load_gki_info_file(args.gki_info,
-                           args.extra_args,
-                           args.extra_footer_args)
+        load_gki_info_file(args.gki_info, args.extra_args)
 
     return args
 
 
-def certify_bootimg(boot_img, output_img, algorithm, key, extra_args,
-                    extra_footer_args):
+def certify_bootimg(boot_img, output_img, algorithm, key, extra_args):
     """Certify a GKI boot image by generating and appending a boot_signature."""
     with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as temp_dir:
         boot_tmp = os.path.join(temp_dir, 'boot.tmp')
@@ -257,27 +234,26 @@
         add_certificate(boot_tmp, algorithm, key, extra_args)
 
         avb_partition_size = get_avb_image_size(boot_img)
-        add_avb_footer(boot_tmp, avb_partition_size, extra_footer_args)
+        add_avb_footer(boot_tmp, avb_partition_size)
 
         # We're done, copy the temp image to the final output.
         shutil.copy2(boot_tmp, output_img)
 
 
 def certify_bootimg_archive(boot_img_archive, output_archive,
-                            algorithm, key, extra_args, extra_footer_args):
+                            algorithm, key, extra_args):
     """Similar to certify_bootimg(), but for an archive of boot images."""
     with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as unpack_dir:
         shutil.unpack_archive(boot_img_archive, unpack_dir)
 
         gki_info_file = os.path.join(unpack_dir, 'gki-info.txt')
         if os.path.exists(gki_info_file):
-            load_gki_info_file(gki_info_file, extra_args, extra_footer_args)
+            load_gki_info_file(gki_info_file, extra_args)
 
         for boot_img in glob.glob(os.path.join(unpack_dir, 'boot*.img')):
             print(f'Certifying {os.path.basename(boot_img)} ...')
             certify_bootimg(boot_img=boot_img, output_img=boot_img,
-                            algorithm=algorithm, key=key, extra_args=extra_args,
-                            extra_footer_args=extra_footer_args)
+                            algorithm=algorithm, key=key, extra_args=extra_args)
 
         print(f'Making certified archive: {output_archive}')
         archive_file_name, archive_format = (
@@ -299,11 +275,10 @@
 
     if args.boot_img_archive:
         certify_bootimg_archive(args.boot_img_archive, args.output,
-                                args.algorithm, args.key, args.extra_args,
-                                args.extra_footer_args)
+                                args.algorithm, args.key, args.extra_args)
     else:
         certify_bootimg(args.boot_img, args.output, args.algorithm,
-                        args.key, args.extra_args, args.extra_footer_args)
+                        args.key, args.extra_args)
 
 
 if __name__ == '__main__':
diff --git a/gki/certify_bootimg_test.py b/gki/certify_bootimg_test.py
index ec5f505..fd7473b 100644
--- a/gki/certify_bootimg_test.py
+++ b/gki/certify_bootimg_test.py
@@ -219,197 +219,6 @@
         # C0103: invalid-name for maxDiff.
         self.maxDiff = None  # pylint: disable=C0103
 
-        # For AVB footers, we don't sign it so the Authentication block
-        # is zero bytes and the Algorithm is NONE. The footer will be
-        # replaced by device-specific settings when being incorporated into
-        # a device codebase. The footer here is just to pass some GKI
-        # pre-release test.
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_CERTIFIED = (    # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               131072 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      24576 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            24576\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              576 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          320 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            24576 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            'c9b4ad78fae6f72f7eff939dee6078ed'
-            '8a75132e53f6c11ba1ec0f4b57f9eab0\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-        )
-
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_CERTIFIED_2 = (  # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               131072 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      24576 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            24576\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              576 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          320 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            24576 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            'ae2538e78b2a30b1112cede30d858a5f'
-            '6f8dc2a1b109dd4a7bb28124b77d2ab0\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-        )
-
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_WITH_GKI_INFO = (     # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               131072 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      24576 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            24576\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              704 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          448 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            24576 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            '363d4f246a4a5e1bba8ba8b86f5eb0cf'
-            '9817e4e51663ba26edccf71c3861090a\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.os_version -> '13'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.security_patch -> '2022-05-05'\n"
-        )
-
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT = (              # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               131072 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      28672 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            28672\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              704 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          448 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            28672 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            'b93084707ba2367120e19547f17f1073'
-            '4c7ad8e56008ec2159d5f01b950335ad\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.os_version -> '13'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.security_patch -> '2022-05-05'\n"
-        )
-
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_LZ4 = (          # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               262144 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      36864 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            36864\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              704 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          448 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            36864 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            '6b3f583f1bc5fbc284102e0185d02c6b'
-            '294f675c95b9337e89ea1e6b743af2ab\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.os_version -> '13'\n"
-            "    Prop: com.android.build.boot.security_patch -> '2022-05-05'\n"
-        )
-
-        self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_GZ = (           # pylint: disable=C0103
-            'Footer version:           1.0\n'
-            'Image size:               131072 bytes\n'
-            'Original image size:      28672 bytes\n'
-            'VBMeta offset:            28672\n'
-            'VBMeta size:              576 bytes\n'
-            '--\n'
-            'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
-            'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
-            'Authentication Block:     0 bytes\n'
-            'Auxiliary Block:          320 bytes\n'
-            'Algorithm:                NONE\n'
-            'Rollback Index:           0\n'
-            'Flags:                    0\n'
-            'Rollback Index Location:  0\n'
-            "Release String:           'avbtool 1.2.0'\n"
-            'Descriptors:\n'
-            '    Hash descriptor:\n'
-            '      Image Size:            28672 bytes\n'
-            '      Hash Algorithm:        sha256\n'
-            '      Partition Name:        boot\n'
-            '      Salt:                  a11ba11b\n'
-            '      Digest:                '
-            'd2098d507e039afc6b4d7ec3de129a8d'
-            'd0e0cf889c9181ebee65ce2fb25de3f5\n'
-            '      Flags:                 0\n'
-            "    Prop: avb -> 'nice'\n"
-            "    Prop: avb_space -> 'nice to meet you'\n"
-        )
-
         self._EXPECTED_BOOT_SIGNATURE_RSA2048 = (       # pylint: disable=C0103
             'Minimum libavb version:   1.0\n'
             'Header Block:             256 bytes\n'
@@ -838,8 +647,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa2048.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--output', boot_certified_img,
             ]
             subprocess.run(certify_bootimg_cmds, check=True, cwd=self._exec_dir)
@@ -848,13 +655,7 @@
             self.assertTrue(has_avb_footer(boot_certified_img))
             self.assertEqual(os.path.getsize(boot_img),
                              os.path.getsize(boot_certified_img))
-            # Checks the content in the AVB footer.
-            self._test_boot_signatures(
-                temp_out_dir,
-                {'boot-certified.img':
-                    self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_CERTIFIED})
 
-            # Checks the content in the GKI certificate.
             extract_boot_signatures(boot_certified_img, temp_out_dir)
             self._test_boot_signatures(
                 temp_out_dir,
@@ -871,8 +672,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa4096.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--output', boot_certified2_img,
             ]
             subprocess.run(certify_bootimg_cmds, check=True, cwd=self._exec_dir)
@@ -881,13 +680,7 @@
             self.assertTrue(has_avb_footer(boot_certified2_img))
             self.assertEqual(os.path.getsize(boot_certified_img),
                              os.path.getsize(boot_certified2_img))
-            # Checks the content in the AVB footer.
-            self._test_boot_signatures(
-                temp_out_dir,
-                {'boot-certified2.img':
-                    self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_CERTIFIED_2})
 
-            # Checks the content in the GKI certificate.
             extract_boot_signatures(boot_certified2_img, temp_out_dir)
             self._test_boot_signatures(
                 temp_out_dir,
@@ -907,11 +700,7 @@
                         '-android13-0-00544-ged21d463f856 '
                         '--prop BRANCH:android13-5.10-2022-05 '
                         '--prop BUILD_NUMBER:ab8295296 '
-                        '--prop GKI_INFO:"added here"\n'
-                        'certify_bootimg_extra_footer_args='
-                        '--prop com.android.build.boot.os_version:13 '
-                        '--prop com.android.build.boot.security_patch:'
-                        '2022-05-05\n')
+                        '--prop GKI_INFO:"added here"\n')
             gki_info_path = os.path.join(temp_out_dir, 'gki-info.txt')
             with open(gki_info_path, 'w', encoding='utf-8') as f:
                 f.write(gki_info)
@@ -926,8 +715,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa4096.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--gki_info', gki_info_path,
                 '--output', boot_certified_img,
             ]
@@ -938,12 +725,6 @@
             self.assertEqual(os.path.getsize(boot_img),
                              os.path.getsize(boot_certified_img))
 
-            # Checks the content in the AVB footer.
-            self._test_boot_signatures(
-                temp_out_dir,
-                {'boot-certified.img': self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_WITH_GKI_INFO})
-
-            # Checks the content in the GKI certificate.
             extract_boot_signatures(boot_certified_img, temp_out_dir)
             self._test_boot_signatures(
                 temp_out_dir,
@@ -990,11 +771,7 @@
                         '-android13-0-00544-ged21d463f856 '
                         '--prop BRANCH:android13-5.10-2022-05 '
                         '--prop BUILD_NUMBER:ab8295296 '
-                        '--prop SPACE:"nice to meet you"\n'
-                        'certify_bootimg_extra_footer_args='
-                        '--prop com.android.build.boot.os_version:13 '
-                        '--prop com.android.build.boot.security_patch:'
-                        '2022-05-05\n')
+                        '--prop SPACE:"nice to meet you"\n')
             boot_img_archive_path = generate_test_boot_image_archive(
                 boot_img_archive_name,
                 'gztar',
@@ -1013,8 +790,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa4096.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--output', boot_certified_img_archive,
             ]
             subprocess.run(certify_bootimg_cmds, check=True, cwd=self._exec_dir)
@@ -1031,13 +806,6 @@
             self.assertTrue(has_avb_footer(boot_lz4_img))
             self.assertEqual(os.path.getsize(boot_lz4_img), 256 * 1024)
 
-            # Checks the content in the AVB footer.
-            self._test_boot_signatures(
-                temp_out_dir,
-                {'boot.img': self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT,
-                 'boot-lz4.img': self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_LZ4})
-
-            # Checks the content in the GKI certificate.
             self._test_boot_signatures(
                 temp_out_dir,
                 {'boot/boot_signature1':
@@ -1072,8 +840,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa4096.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--output', boot_certified_img_archive,
             ]
             subprocess.run(certify_bootimg_cmds, check=True, cwd=self._exec_dir)
@@ -1097,8 +863,6 @@
                 '--key', './testdata/testkey_rsa4096.pem',
                 '--extra_args', '--prop gki:nice '
                 '--prop space:"nice to meet you"',
-                '--extra_footer_args', '--salt a11ba11b --prop avb:nice '
-                '--prop avb_space:"nice to meet you"',
                 '--output', boot_certified_img_archive2,
             ]
             subprocess.run(certify_bootimg_cmds, check=True, cwd=self._exec_dir)
@@ -1111,12 +875,6 @@
             self.assertTrue(has_avb_footer(boot_3_img))
             self.assertEqual(os.path.getsize(boot_3_img), 128 * 1024)
 
-            # Checks the content in the AVB footer.
-            self._test_boot_signatures(
-                temp_out_dir,
-                {'boot-gz.img': self._EXPECTED_AVB_FOOTER_BOOT_GZ})
-
-            # Checks the content in the GKI certificate.
             self._test_boot_signatures(
                 temp_out_dir,
                 {'boot-gz/boot_signature1':